adrianwarnock.com Adrian Warnock
This Site:


Linked Sites:


Friday, November 11, 2005

Questions from a reader for cessationists


correspondent asked me the following questions and agreed for me to
put them to my blog readers:

One question for cessationists would concern John 16:13:

When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth, for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come.
In micro terms, what does that mean?� Pastor Shaun and other cessationists might say that these words were literally for Jesus' 11 disciples (Judas having gone out) and no one else. Slighly broader, a cessationist might say this text is for the canon-forming era only, not just the 11 and Matthias and Paul.

If cessationists don�t believe John 16:13 applies to us today (and perhaps they do) they have to make the case for restricting Jesus� words to the Eleven or to the first century apostles. Prima facie Jesus� words are for all believers unless cessationists cans show why it should be restricted only to first century Apostles. Perhaps they can.

Let�s say John 16:13 is for believers today as well as the Eleven. My question: if the Spirit is promised by Jesus to come and guide us into all truth, how does that work in the most micro of situations?

What does that look like?� To be sure, at the least it means through Scripture. But is that all it means?� For those who are opposed to "impressions", how does the Spirit guide us into "all" truth? If one denies impressions, then does one deny that the Spirit can "bring to mind" Scriptural texts? Or do cessationists interpret this promise to mean the Spirit can bring Scriptures to mind but nothing else?� But even bringing Scriptures to mind seems to me like...an impression.

Related, James tell us to ask for wisdom. How does that work in micro terms?

Let's take the moment immediately preceding God's answer of that prayer when one lacks wisdom. What specifically changes from the moment of lacking wisdom to the moment of receiving wisdom from God? What constitutes the actual wisdom-- words? thoughts? arguments? discernment?��

So a related question would be, for the type of cessationist that denies impressions, how does such a cessationist distinguish between wisdom given by God and impressions?

More Headlines From This Blog
Back to homepage or visit the archive pages April 2003  May 2003  June 2003  July 2003  August 2003  September 2003  October 2003  November 2003  December 2003  January 2004  February 2004  March 2004  April 2004  May 2004  June 2004  July 2004  August 2004  September 2004  October 2004  November 2004  December 2004  January 2005  February 2005  March 2005  April 2005  May 2005  June 2005  July 2005  August 2005  September 2005  October 2005  November 2005  December 2005  January 2006  February 2006  March 2006  April 2006  May 2006  June 2006  July 2006  August 2006  September 2006  October 2006  November 2006  December 2006  January 2007  February 2007  March 2007  April 2007  May 2007  June 2007  July 2007  August 2007  September 2007  October 2007  November 2007  December 2007  January 2008  February 2008  March 2008  April 2008  May 2008  June 2008  July 2008  August 2008  September 2008  October 2008 
Add to Google Reader / Homepage

Subscribe via RSS feed or enter your email address here:

My Library

ADRIAN'S LINKS

In partnership with the Jollyblogger


WARNIE AWARD WINNERS


Reformed Charismatic Blogs

Other Links


25% Off Logos Bible Software

YOUR ADVERT HERE

MY INTERVIEWS


Sermons on the Web


Previous Posts

Associated with

Small print

Opinions expressed in this blog are Adrian Warnock's alone, and do not represent the views of his church, employer or anyone else for that matter!

Material is often provided for your research purposes rather than as an endorsement. We ask you to report anything you see here or on a linked site that you feel may be inappropriate or may inadvertently breach copyright to adrian.warnock@gmail.com.

Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial No-Derivs 2.0 England & Wales License.

ESV
Unless otherwise indicated, all bible quotations are from The English Standard Version © 2001, Crossway Bibles. Used by permission. All rights reserved. See my ESV Interview for more information

Services by:

Christianity Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory

Powered by Blogger